Ila Reindeer Mailbox Topper US

The Craftsman’s Review
Stories From America’s Workshops, Kitchens & Front Porches
Advertisement

“Her mailbox flag stayed down for three weeks. I put a reindeer on it, and the next morning the flag was up.” — Why a 71-year-old rural mail carrier from Vermont is letting go of her last mailbox reindeer at a special price, before her route goes quiet for good.

Ila Kittredge with one of her reindeer on a mailbox outside Hardwick, Vermont.
Ila Kittredge with one of her reindeer on a mailbox outside Hardwick, Vermont.

On the first Monday of December, Ila Kittredge puts on her red wool hat, fills a thermos with coffee and drives out to Route 2. She is not delivering mail anymore. She is delivering reindeer.

Ila is 71. She lives in Hardwick, a small town in the far north of Vermont, where the snow comes in October and stays until April. For 34 winters, from 1985 to 2019, she was the rural mail carrier on Route 2. That is 112 miles of dirt and mountain roads and 486 mailboxes, six days a week.

She knows every family on that road by first name. And she knows something only a mail carrier knows.

“You always know who lives alone. Their mailbox only ever gets bills. At Christmas, some boxes get 40 cards. Some get none.”

The widow whose flag stayed down

December 1989: the very first reindeer on Route 2.
December 1989: the very first reindeer on Route 2.

In November 1989, Winona Morse on Bridgman Hill Road lost her husband. After that, her red mailbox flag stayed down. Mail piled up inside. For three weeks, she did not come out to the road.

Ila did not know what to say to her. So she went to her father, Arlo, who carved wood in the shed behind the house. She asked him for something small and happy. He carved a reindeer head from a scrap of pine and gave it a red bead for a nose.

The next morning, Ila tied it onto Winona’s mailbox with a red rubber band from a bundle of mail. She did not leave a name.

“The next day, her flag was up. Inside was a note: ‘Thank you, whoever you are.’ I cried for the whole rest of the route.”

From one reindeer to 61 on a single road

That was the start. Every year after that, on the first Monday of December, every mailbox on Route 2 with someone living alone behind it got a reindeer. Widows. Old farmers. A young soldier’s wife whose husband was overseas.

In 1989 there was one. By 2019, there were 61. Ila never signed a single one. People on the road just called them “Ila’s reindeer,” and most never knew it was really her.

“Up here, the whole road is white and gray for four months. That little red nose was the only color for miles. People waved at it.”

The coffee can full of rubber bands

The 1989 original, the rubber band can, and the reindeer that was made from it.
The 1989 original, the rubber band can, and the reindeer that was made from it.

After she retired, Ila kept carving at her father’s old workbench. On the windowsill, there is still a coffee can full of red rubber bands from 34 years of mail bundles. Next to it sits the very first reindeer, the paint chipped, the nose a little crooked.

Then the arthritis came. First in her right hand, then in both. Her granddaughter Brynn, 26, had an idea. She measured the 1989 reindeer and had a small decor maker build it in a run, exactly the way Ila wanted it.

It is not hand-carved anymore, and Ila says so herself. But it has the same face, the same red nose, the same green and berries she used to tie on. And every single one goes past her kitchen table before it goes into the box.

What 34 winters on Route 2 taught her about a mailbox

About 7.9 inches tall. The door and the red flag stay free, so the mail still comes.
About 7.9 inches tall. The door and the red flag stay free, so the mail still comes.
  • “The Rubber-Band Hold”: In 1989 it was a rubber band from a mail bundle. Now it is an adjustable rubber strap that goes around a standard mailbox. No drilling, no screws. “Thirty seconds, and it’s on.”
  • “The Plow-Wind Footing”: A non-slip rubber base on the bottom. “When the town plow goes by at 40 miles an hour, it throws snow and wind at everything. The reindeer has to stay put.”
  • “The Flag-Side Rule”: It sits on the roof of the mailbox, not in front of it. “Never block the door or the flag. That’s the first thing a mail carrier will tell you.”
  • “The Northeast Kingdom Finish”: Made for outdoors, against rain, snow and fading. Pine green, red berries, pine cones and a red plaid bow, already in place. “Nothing to tie, nothing to glue.”

The note she still keeps in her kitchen drawer

Winona Morse lived another 14 years. Every December, her flag went up the day the reindeer came. Ila still has the note from 1989, folded in her kitchen drawer next to the matches.

“People think it’s a decoration. It’s not. It tells somebody: you are not forgotten out here.”

The morning the knife fell out of her hand

The last boxes in Ilas spare room. There will not be another run.
The last boxes in Ila’s spare room. There will not be another run.

For 34 years, Ila leaned out of the car window to reach the mailboxes on her right. Mail carriers call it “carrier’s shoulder.” Today she can barely lift her right arm above her head.

Last winter, she tried to carve the reindeer one more time. She managed nine. It took her all of November. Then one morning her father’s knife slipped out of her fingers and hit the floor.

“I just sat there and looked at it. My dad’s knife, on the floor. I knew right then this Christmas would be the last one.”

What is left sits in her spare room: 68 reindeer from the final run. When they are gone, there will not be any more of Ila’s reindeer.

Why she wants you to give the second one away

When photos of the reindeer started going around a Vermont Facebook group, a liquidation company called. They wanted to take all 68 at once. Ila said no.

“I don’t need the money. I want 68 more mailboxes with a red nose on them this Christmas.”

So she set what she calls her “last route price,” far below what they are worth. Brynn built a small online page. And Ila has one request for everybody who orders:

“Get one for your own mailbox. And if you can, one for a neighbor who lives alone. And please, don’t sign it.”

While supplies last: the last 68 reindeer from Ila’s final run, at her last route price.

See the Last Reindeer

Check availability →

What people say about Ila’s reindeer

A neighbors mailbox in Ohio, two days after the reindeer arrived.
A neighbor’s mailbox in Ohio, two days after the reindeer arrived.
  • ★★★★★

    “I bought two. One for me, and one I put on Mrs. Hall’s mailbox across the road. She’s 88 and lives alone. She hasn’t figured out it was me.”

    Patricia L., Medina, OH
  • ★★★★★

    “The strap went on in a minute, no tools. We had a nasty ice storm last week and it didn’t move an inch. The grandkids wave at it every morning.”

    Gary M., Rutland, VT
  • ★★★★★

    “It’s not big, about eight inches, so don’t expect a giant. But on a black mailbox with the red bow, it looks just like an old Christmas card.”

    Donna R., Asheville, NC

Three questions people ask before ordering

Where can I buy Ila’s reindeer?

Only through this page. Ila’s reindeer mailbox topper is not sold on Amazon, Temu or in any other store.

How long will it be available?

Only while supplies last. This Christmas is Ila’s last, and there are 68 reindeer left from the final run. Once they are gone, there will not be any more.

What if it’s not right for me?

You have 30 days to try it on your own mailbox. If you are not happy, just send a short email and you will get your money back. No questions, no hassle.

December is here. Put a red nose on your mailbox, or on the mailbox of someone who could use a little surprise this Christmas.

Check Availability

Limited stock — only 68 reindeer left

More words from people on Ila’s list

  • ★★★★★

    “I grew up on Route 2. We had one of Ila’s reindeer the winter my dad died. When I heard this was the last run, I ordered three.”

    Karen B., Hardwick, VT
  • ★★★★★

    “Our mail carrier left a note in the box: ‘Best mailbox on my route.’ That made my whole week.”

    Sharon T., Lancaster, PA
  • ★★★★★

    “The pine cones, the berries, the plaid bow. It looks like real farmhouse Christmas. It comes off in January and goes right back in the box for next year.”

    Linda W., Lebanon, MO