Edna Sourdough Dough Warmer UK

The Craftsman’s Review
Stories From Britain’s Workshops, Kitchens & Kitchen Tables
Advertisement

“My mother wrapped the bread bowl in her wedding eiderdown every winter night. I’ve been trying to replace that eiderdown for 65 years.” — Why a 74-year-old Yorkshire Dales bread champion is letting go of her last dough warmers at a special price, before she teaches her final bread class for good.

Edna Metcalfe lifts the cloth off a bowl of risen dough on the dough warmer at her village hall bread class
Tuesday night bread class in the village hall in Askrigg, Wensleydale. On 16 December, Edna teaches it for the last time.

Every Tuesday at six o’clock, Edna Metcalfe lifts a linen cloth off a glass bowl in the village hall in Askrigg. Twelve people lean in to look. The dough has doubled. Somebody always says “oh.”

Edna is 74. She has won 41 first prizes for her bread at the Wensleydale Show. Since 1994 she has taught bread every Tuesday night in the village hall kitchen. About 1,100 people have learned to bake from her.

On the chalkboard behind her, in the same spot for 31 years, is her rule number one.

“Dough doesn’t care about your recipe. It cares about the temperature.”

The eiderdown by the kitchen range

1959: Edna watches her mother tuck the bread bowl into her wedding eiderdown beside the kitchen range
Edna, seven years old, in her mother’s farmhouse kitchen above Askrigg in the winter of 1959.

It started on a farm above Askrigg in the winter of 1959. The fog sat in the dale for a fortnight. Edna was seven.

Every night, her mother Lilian set the bread dough in a big bowl beside the kitchen range. Then she wrapped it in the eiderdown from her own wedding.

“My mother tucked the bread in at night like it was one of us. If the range went out, there was no bread in the morning.”

Some mornings the range did go out. The dough sat flat in the bowl, cold and heavy. Edna never forgot the look on her mother’s face.

She has spent the rest of her life chasing that warm spot beside the range.

A perfect dough in class, a doorstop at home

Edna at the chalkboard in the village hall kitchen, with sourdough starter jars and the dough warmer
Rule number one has stayed on the same chalkboard since 1994.

For years, Edna tried everything. The oven with only the light on. The top of the fridge. The airing cupboard. An electric blanket under a tea towel.

Her students had the same trouble. In class, the hall kitchen was warm and the dough rose beautifully. At home, in a stone cottage kitchen at 12 degrees in February, the same dough just sat there.

“They came back the next Tuesday with a loaf you could prop a door open with. Same recipe, same flour. Only the kitchen was colder.”

That is the bit people get wrong about a British winter. It is rarely dramatic. It is 3 degrees and damp outside, 12 or 13 in the kitchen, and it stays that way from November to April. Bread dough wants 26.

Nobody sold what she needed, so she drew it herself

Edna Metcalfe with her home-made proving attempts: a polystyrene cool box, an electric blanket and a plastic box with an aquarium thermostat
Forty years of trying: the 1986 cool box with a light bulb in it, the electric blanket years, and the plastic box from 2011.

So Edna improvised. In 1986 it was a polystyrene cool box with a 25-watt bulb inside and a hole in the lid for a meat thermometer. It worked until the bulb went, or until it cooked one side of the dough.

Then came years of electric blankets under folded tea towels. In 2011, an aquarium thermostat in a plastic box from the hardware shop in Leyburn. That one finally held a temperature. It still wasn’t right.

“Every box I rigged up kept the air warm. The dough in the middle never got the message.”

That was the thing nobody sold her. Every proving box on the market measures the air. Edna wanted to measure the dough. In the winter of 2019 she drew what she actually needed on the back of a class handout: a flat plate instead of a box, so any bowl would fit. A probe that goes into the dough. One steady temperature. And a timer that switches the whole thing off while she sleeps.

Cliff Alderson soldering the first prototype at his workbench while Edna Metcalfe points at the board
Her son-in-law Cliff at his workbench in 2019. The drawing on the bench is hers, the soldering iron is his.

She took the handout to her son-in-law, Clifford Alderson, a retired electrician in Leyburn. He built it: a pine board, a heating plate, a dial, a steel probe. Edna is the first to say that part was never hers.

“I couldn’t wire a lamp to save my life. But I knew exactly what it had to do.”

They went back and forth all that winter. She sent the first board back because the probe sat too shallow in the dough. The second one because the dial jumped two degrees when the heating came on. On the third, she set her dough at nine at night. By morning it had doubled.

“Cliff built it. But every number on it is mine.”
Edna Metcalfe at her kitchen table with the first prototype and her pencil sketch, the finished warmer behind it
The prototype Cliff built from her drawing, next to the version her students buy today.

Her Tuesday students all wanted one. Since 2022 a small electrical workshop in Leyburn has built them in small runs, to her drawing and her numbers: the walnut-look plate, the copper dial, the display. Edna orders a box every autumn for her class and passes them on for close to what she pays. She still unpacks every run and checks one.

“It’s my mother’s eiderdown. Except it never lets the fire go out.”

The four things she wrote on the back of that handout

The steel probe of the dough warmer sits in the middle of a bowl of risen dough
The steel probe sits in the middle of the dough, where it counts.

Those four lines are still exactly what the warmer does. Edna explains them the way she explains bread: plainly.

  • “The Inside Thermometer”: A thin steel probe goes right into the dough and shows its real temperature on the display. “The outside of the dough lies to you. The middle never does.”
  • “The Half-Degree Hold”: Set it anywhere from 21 to 49 degrees and it stays within half a degree. “26 for bread dough. A little warmer for a sleepy starter.”
  • “The All-Night Watch”: A timer runs up to 24 hours, then the warmer switches itself off. “Set the dough at night, go to bed, bake in the morning. My mother would have loved that.”
  • “The Any-Bowl Base”: A Kilner jar, a glass bowl or a steel mixing bowl. It holds up to four and a half litres of dough. “And it fits in the cupboard when you’re done.”

Edna uses it for more than bread, too. Softening butter for her teacakes. Keeping yoghurt warm overnight. But bread is the reason she keeps one on her worktop all winter.

“I judged bread at the Wensleydale Show for 30 years. I could always tell an Edna student. Their loaves stood up tall. The last few winters, they stood up tall in February too.”

Judith Sowerby, longtime bread judge, Wensleydale Show, North Yorkshire

The last Tuesday

Edna in the village hall store cupboard with the last boxed dough warmers
The last boxes of warmers in the village hall store cupboard, next to the flour Edna can no longer carry.

Every Tuesday for 31 years, Edna carried a 16-kilo sack of flour up the steps to the village hall. She kneaded the big demonstration dough by hand, in front of the whole class.

Her right shoulder can’t do it anymore. This autumn her doctor told her plainly: no more lifting, no more kneading.

“My hands still know bread dough by feel. My shoulder just won’t let me show anyone how anymore.”

She will miss the smell of the hall kitchen on a Tuesday night. The quiet moment when a new student pulls a tall loaf out of the oven for the first time.

The class on 16 December will be her last. The spring classes are cancelled. In the village hall store cupboard, there is one box left from the last run she had built in Leyburn. 54 dough warmers. Without the class she will not order another run, and nobody else will.

Why she said no to the kitchen shop

A kitchen shop in Harrogate heard about the box. They offered to take all 54 at once. One cheque, and done.

Edna said no.

“I don’t want them on a shop shelf. I want them in 54 kitchens where somebody still bakes bread.”

She priced them close to what she paid herself. She could have asked for more, and nobody would have blamed her. That was never the point. She wants 54 more people to pull a tall loaf out of the oven this winter, the way her mother did on the good mornings.

Her granddaughter Ellie set up the little online page. Edna still writes a note for the first few boxes herself.

While supplies last: Edna’s last 54 dough warmers from her bread class, at her closing price.

See the Last Warmers

Check availability →

What her students say about Edna’s warmer

  • ★★★★★

    “My kitchen sits at 12 degrees all winter and my bread was always heavy. First loaf on Edna’s warmer came out light and tall. My husband asked what I’d done differently.”

    Kathleen J., Skipton, North Yorkshire
  • ★★★★★

    “I set my dough at nine at night and it’s ready at seven in the morning. The little probe tells me exactly how warm it is inside. No more guessing.”

    Ruth P., Kendal, Cumbria
  • ★★★★★

    “I bought two, one for me and one for my son who has just started baking sourdough. It’s smaller than I expected and fits straight in the cupboard.”

    Linda W., Barnard Castle, County Durham

Three questions people ask before ordering

Where can I buy Edna’s dough warmer?

Only through this page. Edna’s dough warmers are not sold on Amazon, Temu or in any other shop.

How long will they be available?

Only while supplies last. Edna teaches her last class on 16 December, and there are 54 warmers left. Once they are gone, there will not be any more.

What if it’s not right for me?

You have 30 days to try it in your own kitchen. If you are not happy, just send a short email and you will get your money back. No questions, no fuss.

One last lesson from Edna’s Tuesday class, on your own kitchen worktop. Keep one for your winter baking, or give one to someone who loves fresh bread as much as she does.

Check Availability

Limited stock — only 54 warmers left

More words from Edna’s students

  • ★★★★★

    “I took Edna’s Tuesday class in 2009. My bread only rose in summer. Now it rises in February too. I wish I’d had this 15 years ago.”

    Maureen A., Hawes, North Yorkshire
  • ★★★★★

    “My starter used to go sleepy every winter. On the warmer at 27 degrees it’s bubbling again by lunchtime. So easy to use.”

    Gloria M., Ilkley, West Yorkshire
  • ★★★★★

    “Gave one to my daughter for Christmas along with my mother’s bread recipe. She sent me a photo of her first loaf. Tall as anything.”

    Marlene O., Richmond, North Yorkshire